" />

Comentarii Adauga Comentariu

The Guardian critica BBC-ul ca trece sub tacere mortii palestinieni. " 'Israel sub un nou atac Hamas', spune BBC. E necesara mai multa obiectivitate"

THE GUARDIAN: 'Israel under renewed Hamas attack', says the BBC. More balance is needed


by Owen Jones

theguardian.com, Wednesday 9 July 2014 11.02 BST

The macabre truth is that Israeli life is deemed by the western media to be worth more than a Palestinian life – this is the hierarchy of death at work

"Israel under renewed Hamas attack": this was last night's BBC headline on the escalating bloodshed in Gaza. It is as perverse as Mike Tyson punching a toddler, followed by a headline claiming that the child spat at him. As Elizabeth Tsurkov, a Tel Aviv-based Israeli human rights activist, tweeted: "We are targeted by mostly shitty rockets. Gazans are being shelled with heavy bombs. We have shelters, sirens, Iron Dome. They have 0."

There is no defence for Hamas firing rockets into civilian areas, and as sirens wail in Israel, the fear among ordinary Israelis should not be ignored or belittled.

But the media coverage hardly reflects the reality: a military superpower armed with F-15 fighter jets, AH-64 Apache helicopters, Delilah missiles, IAI Heron-1 drones and Jericho II missiles (and nuclear bombs, for that matter), versus what David Cameron describes as a "prison camp" firing almost entirely ineffective missiles. Twenty-seven Palestinians are reported to have died in Gaza – and, mercifully, no Israelis have been killed by Hamas rockets – and yet the BBC opts for the Orwellian "Israel under renewed Hamas attack".

The macabre truth is that Israeli life is deemed by the western media to be worth more than a Palestinian life: here is the "hierarchy of death" at work. According to the Israeli human rights organisation B'Tselem, 565 Palestinians have been killed by Israeli security forces since January 2009, while 28 Israeli civilians and 10 Israeli security personnel have been killed. The asymmetry of this so-called conflict is reflected in the death toll, but it is not reflected in the coverage.

And so it goes for the events surrounding the abduction and vile murder of three Israeli teenagers. What was not widely reported by the western media was that – in the raids that followed their disappearance – six Palestinians, including a child, were killed by Israeli forces in the West Bank. As Amnesty International put it, these were "blatant violations of international humanitarian and human rights law".

Perhaps our media will excuse themselves on the basis of motive: whoever killed the three teenagers intended to do so, while Israel only kills civilians unintentionally.

Read, then, the report of Human Rights Watch, not an organisation that can be accused of being a den of lefties.

Israel's actions "amounted to collective punishment", it declared, because of "unlawful use of force, arbitrary arrests, and illegal home demolitions".

Human Rights Watch investigated two deaths and found "there was no evidence that the victim or anyone in the line of fire posed an imminent threat to Israeli soldiers or others".

On 17 June, 20-year-old Ahmed Samada was shot dead in Jalazon refugee camp, and yet Israel did not even claim to have come under fire; the same for 17-year-old Sakher Abu Aal-Hasan, shot dead on 21 June.

The BBC is a public broadcaster, duty-bound to provide balanced reports that accurately reflect the reality on the ground. It is failing to do so, and it is up to licence payers – to whom it is accountable – to demand that it does.

Ramadan in Gaza: life under missile-fire

More than 100 have died – often women and children in their own homes – and food prices are rising fast as supplies dry up

Peter Beaumont in Gaza City

The Guardian, Friday 11 July 2014 17.56 BST

The beach, usually crowded on Friday afternoons, is empty save for a handful of fishermen casting hand nets into the surf next to the harbour wall.

Al-Azhar park – next to the university of the same name – and Barcelona park with its climbing frames, lawns and basketball courts, are empty.

The few children who are outside play in the sheltered spaces between tall apartment blocks and the narrow lanes of the poorer neighbourhoods, a few feet from their doors under the watchful eyes of their parents: places deemed safer from bomb blasts.

It is the fourth day of Israel's intensive bombing campaign of the Gaza Strip, and more than 100 Palestinians have been killed, many of them children. More than 670 are injured. Families here have settled into a tense wartime regime, a daily routine hard-learned from Israel's previous military campaigns of 2008-09 and 2012.

Unlike Israel, there are no bomb shelters in Gaza. There are no sirens to warn of incoming missiles and no Iron Dome to shoot them down. The only warning, and one provided only intermittently, is that from those dropping the bombs – supplied by phone, text or a warning shot to the roof.

Under the ever-present hum of circling drones, squeal of jets, bomb-blasts and the thud of naval gunfire from the sea, most women and children are stuck indoors, often in buildings without electricity.

These families have been caught in a tragic catch-22. Afraid to leave their homes when the Israeli warplanes do drop their bombs on Gaza's neighbourhoods, it is the women and children sheltering in the buildings where they instinctively feel safest who are dying.

Israel has said it is training its missiles on Gaza's homes – a practice the United Nations Human Rights Office says may violate international law – because Hamas and other militants are hiding inside.

"We have received disturbing reports that many of the civilian casualties, including of children, occurred as a result of strikes on homes," Ravina Shamdasani, a UN spokeswoman said on Thursday.

"Such reports raise doubts about whether the Israeli air strikes have been in accordance with international humanitarian law and international human rights law."

The Israeli prime minister, Binyamin Netanyahu, has rejected the criticism of international and local human rights groups and vowed to continue with the campaign. "No international pressure will prevent Israel from continuing its operation in Gaza … The leaders of Hamas are hiding behind the citizens of Gaza, and they are responsible for all casualties," he said.

For the 1.8 million people living in Gaza, this means that long Ramadan days – from before dawn until the late bedtime traditional during the fasting month – will continue to be defined by limited exposure to the open air.

Gaza City's central Firas market is usually packed with shoppers shoulder to shoulder, looking for fruit and vegetables after noon prayers. This Friday a few people were bustling along its lanes. Hamdi Haboush, 63, sat outside the hardware store where he sells brush heads and squeegees, spice racks and spades. "I haven't had any customers at all today," he said. "I only opened because I couldn't bear staying in the house. There are 50 of my family in our building, including twenty grandchildren.

"It's only really me who is going to early prayers at the moment [at four in the morning]. But it's the most frightening time for bombs so I walk close to the walls on my way to mosque.

"Otherwise no-one is going out. There's no work and nothing to do. Nowhere safe to go. Everyone is in a state of panic wondering when a bomb will fall.

"We have two metres square of space where the younger children can play. Last night some of the grandchildren came to me and said: 'Why are you going to open your shop? It's scary.' But I have to come out to change my mood."

Other men standing or sitting by their empty shops and stalls said the same. There is no money to be made – only relief from households going "crazy".

If, as Haboush says, early morning prayers are quiet, a steady stream of men and older boys filed in to the main mosque in Radwan for Friday prayers.

Mahmoud Karazem, 30, arrived late and in a hurry. He has grown used to the bombs over the years and different campaigns: "It's normal." Life under advanced missile-fire is not yet normal for his wife and two young toddlers.

"My wife is at home with the children. They are one and a half and almost three. I try to reassure them but when a bomb explodes it bursts the bubble. I cuddle them to get them used it, but sometimes it doesn't work."

The imam began his sermon with a message to worshippers that they were engaged in a fight of "good against evil". Ramadan "is a time of victories" he said before condemning the complicity of America and the international community and "the silence of the Arab world".

Mahmoud Khalija went to buy groceries after midday prayers. A worker at Gaza City's Shifa hospital, he said he is attempting to go about his life as "normally as possible".

"My wife is going to work too," he said. "Our older children stay at home with the youngest. The prices are the biggest problem. There is no fish," he added, indicating a shuttered fish stall. "And because it is so hard for the farmers to harvest and bring their produce to the market, some prices have quadrupled."

Others who had ventured out explained the judgment call: roads exposed to the sea, and therefore to Israel's naval gunships, are to be avoided. Roads bordering farmland where rockets are launched, are driven through quickly, if at all.

In Gaza, wealth cannot inoculate you from fear. In affluent neighbourhoods, where the buildings are taller and more widely spaced, the sound of the dropping missiles rings more loudly and clearly than in the huddled, poorer neighbourhoods and refugee camps. They are also closer to the naval boats pounding the coast with artillery fire.

In Tal al-Hawa, a neighbourhood hit hard in the 2008-09 conflict, Hazem Farwana, 38, a baker, is making Ramadan pancakes. He and his son Samir, 12, sell them for a £1.50 a kilo from a stall in front of a falafel takeaway.

Pancakes are the treat of any Iftar meal at the end of a day of fasting. They are served with nuts, cheese or dates and normally eaten before families go out visiting, sitting up late into the night. But Farwana and his wife have not gone visiting this week: "We are not living a normal life.

"People are stuck indoors. All they can do is eat. I have four children under 16 – I won't let them go too far from home."

As he spoke, a bomb exploded in the distance, close enough for a shockwave to rattle the window frames overhead.

Suddenly philosophical, Farwana added: "If I am going to die then I will die. I can die in the open as easily as I can indoors."


Linkul direct catre Petitie

CEREM NATIONALIZAREA TUTUROR RESURSELOR NATURALE ALE ROMANIEI ! - Initiativa Legislativa care are nevoie de 500.000 de semnaturi - Semneaza si tu !


Adauga Comentariu

Citiți și cele mai căutate articole de pe Fluierul:

Laufer susține ce nu prevede memorandumul semnat în SUA: Asistăm la încă o ocazie ratată de România

Laufer vorbește despre ceea ce nu prevede memorandumul semnat în SUA: Asistăm la încă o ocazie ratată de România

Avionul Egyptair prăbuşit: Analiza uneia din cutiile negre arată că s-a pronunţat cuvântul "foc"

Patru adolescenți, salvați după ce s-au rătăcit în munții Bucegi

Trump califică drept "dezagreabile" afirmațiile premierului danez Mette Frederiksen despre ideea vânzării Groenlandei

Nuclear: Macron se va întâlni cu responsabili iranieni înainte de summitul G7

Copil german de 8 ani surprins pe autostradă în timp ce gonea cu 140 km/h

Ministrul de externe german cere Rusiei și Ucrainei să se reunească pentru noi convorbiri de pace

Rusia și China cer convocarea Consiliului de Securitate ONU, după testul cu o rachetă cu rază medie de acțiune efectuat recent de SUA

RUȘINE. După ce a dat pe nimic austriecilor tot petrolul țării și după ce a dat rușilor aproape toată metalurgia, Adrian Nastase vine și are tupeul să facă pe "patriotul". Adrian Năstase: 'PSD are nevoie de un mesaj mai puternic de natură naționalistă"

IJJ Prahova: Campanie de prevenire cu privire la animalele sălbatice agresive

Rusia și China cer convocarea Consiliului de Securitate ONU după testul cu rachetă efectuat de SUA

Fotbal: Olympiakos Pireu, cu un pas în grupele Ligii Campionilor

Utile: Infarctul miocardic la tineri. Principalele cauze care duc la apariția problemelor de inimă; Mineralul care reduce riscul de boli cardiovasculare și susține sănătatea celulelor

Caru`cu vedete: Rona Hartner, decisă să învingă toate problemele! A stabilit data nunții cu iubitul francez; Actorul Dwayne Johnson s-a căsătorit; Kim Kardashian, surprinsă pe o plajă din Bahamas în timp ce fugea de porci

Săftoiu, către Cîțu: Sunt de acord să mai tăiem de la bugetari, dar e obligatoriu să începem cu noi

Bărbat suspectat că a spart sediul Poliției Cornu, prins

Canada ''nu va ceda'' în fața Chinei, avertizează Trudeau

Stirile ProTV: Viață bună pe bani publici. Angajații CJ Argeș merg la "cursuri" în stațiuni de lux și se amuză de situație

Ludovic Orban îl contrazice pe Florin Cîțu: Nu avem nimic împotriva voucherelor de vacanță

Faze tari: “Călătoria" în lumea Star Wars, posibilă datorită unei tehnici moderne; Elon Musk e speriat de asteroizi și spune că Pământul e complet lipsit de apărare

Întâlnire Dăncilă-patronate: Se va crea un grup de lucru pentru îmbunătățirea mediului de afaceri

Orban, despre anunțul PSD-ALDE privind respingerea amnistiei și grațierii: Ei susțin solicitarea PNL

Statele Unite, acuzate că permit Israelului să atace obiective iraniene din Irak

Tenis: Gabriela Ruse, în ultimul tur al calificărilor la US Open

ALDE susține că nu a ajuns la un consens cu PSD în privința restructurării Guvernului

Adrian Florescu a fost eliberat din funcția de prefect de Gorj și numit secretar de stat în MAI

Doi militari americani au fost uciși în Afganistan

Peskov: Toate statele din G7 ar trebui consultate înaintea unei posibile reveniri la formatul G8

12 copii aflați într-o tabără din Suceava au ajuns la spital, cu toxiinfecție alimentară

Orban: Tăriceanu a încercat să își arate mușchii, dar până la urmă rămâne în guvernarea impotentă

PSD: Domnule Cîțu, începeți dumneavoastră să plecați acasă sub eticheta de "bugetar praf"

2020 – ROMÂNIA și viitorul an bisect

Mihai-Cristian Mărculescu schimbat din funcția de șef al Direcției Generale de Protecție Internă a MAI

Proteste anticomuniste la Praga

Arhitect amendat în Veneția cu 86 de mii de dolari pentru un pod prost executat

Kaiac-canoe: Trei echipaje românești, calificate în semifinale la Mondiale

Dăncilă discută cu Tăriceanu despre soarta coaliției, după ultimatumul dat de ALDE

Peskov: Toate statele din G7 ar trebui consultate înaintea revenirii la formatul G8

Ministrul de Externe a discutat cu ambasadorul armean despre relațiile economice româno-armene

Fotbal: Vergil Andronache (FCSB) - Primordial este să nu primim gol mâine; nu vrem să ne oprim aici

Scenariul central pentru Brexit este cel al unui no-deal" (Președinția Franței)

Putin: Porțiunea finlandeză a conductei de gaze Nord Stream 2 este finalizată

Paranoia Progresistă continuă. Clip publicitar interzis în Marea Britanie, pentru că în el o mamă îşi îngrijeşte bebeluşul "Îngrijirea copiilor a fost un rol care a fost asociat stereotip cu femeile” spune ASA în hotărârea sa de a interzice clipul.

Rusia, dispusă să ''examineze'' o eventuală revenire în G8

Natalia Intotero: Am aflat cu îngrijorare că în Leipzig poliția le cere hotelierilor să anunțe dacă au cazați cetățeni români

Șeful Direcției Generale de Protecție Internă a fost schimbat din funcție (surse)

Un tânăr din Gorj a murit strivit de tavanul unei case unde lucra

BREAKING Un elicopter s-a prăbușit în Rusia după ce a lovit o linie de înaltă tensiune

​US Open: Irina Begu, eliminată în turul al doilea al calificărilor

Eugen Teodorovici îl atacă pe Florin Cîțu: Este dăunător și jignitor cum unii frustrați și ratați profesional sunt tolerați de câte un partid

Baschet masculin: România s-a calificat în preliminariile FIBA EuroBasket 2021

Merkel sugerează că este posibil un acord în următoarele 30 de zile, cu puțină imaginație

România, 2019: Angajatele de la Protecția Consumatorului nu mai au voie să poarte bluze cu decolteu / "Limita de decență" la lungimea fustei - "imediat deasupra genunchilor" / Sandalele și pletele, interzise la bărbați

Macron consideră "pertinent" ca Rusia să revină în G8 "în timp"

Ciprian-Adrian Florescu, numit în funcția de secretar de stat la Ministerul Afacerilor Interne

Doi soldați americani, uciși în Afganistan (NATO)

STENOGRAMA declarațiilor Trump-Iohannis. Cu ce a rămas România, după vizita președintelui în SUA / VIDEO

Presă: Clubul francez OGC Nice va fi cumpărat de compania Ineos pentru 100 de milioane de euro

Barna anunță că dacă USR ajunge la guvernare va elimina pensiile speciale, cu două excepții

Pag.1 Pag.2 Pag.3

Nr. de articole la aceasta sectiune: 138, afisate in 3 pagini.

ieri 05:22 CITATUL ZILEI